Raised Doughnut Recipe
I do love a good yeast-raised doughnut, and in fact in most ways, they’re easier to make than their cake-style counterparts. True, they require some advance planning, but they’re aren’t as fussy in the oil, or as sensitive to ambient temperatures. The best part is, they’re amazingly light, much more so than a store-bought version. Try them once and you’ll be making them every weekend. Oh, and if you want an even fluffier texture, up the gluten content by using bread flour.
For the sponge:
4 ounces (3/4 cup) all-purpose flour
1/2 teaspoon instant yeast
3.5 ounces (half cup minus one tablespoon) lukewarm water
1 large egg
For the doughnuts:
5.75 ounces (1 slightly generous cup) all-purpose flour
1.5 teaspoons instant yeast
0.6 ounces (1/4 cup) milk powder
1/4 teaspoon salt
0.5 ounces (2 1/4 teaspoons) sugar
2 egg yolks
1/2 ounce (1 tablespoon) milk or water
2 teaspoons vanilla extract
3 ounces (6 tablespoons) butter at room temperature
Canola oil for frying
Extra fine sugar for rolling (for jelly doughnuts)
Raspberry or other fruit jam for filling (for jelly doughnuts)
Combine the sponge ingredients in a small bowl and stir them with a fork until smooth. Let the sponge ferment for half an hour at room temperature, then refrigerate overnight.
The next day, put the sponge in the bowl of a stand mixer fitted with a dough hook. Add all the remaining ingredients except the butter. Knead it for 10 minutes on medium speed, scraping down as needed. After 10 minutes, start adding the butter a tablespoon at a time, kneading until each is well incorporated.
Put the dough into a lightly oiled bowl, cover it with plastic wrap, and leave it in a warm place until doubled in size, about 1 hour. On a lightly floured surface, roll the dough out to a thickness of 3/8 inches. Using a 3 1/2-inch circular cookie cutter, cut out the doughnuts, re-rolling the scraps until the dough is completely used. If making jelly doughnuts, leave the dough circles intact. Otherwise, use a small 3/4″ circular cutter to punch out holes in the center. Return the doughnuts to the towel-lined baking sheet, covered with a sheet of lightly oiled plastic wrap. Let them rise until puffy, 30-45 minutes.
Fry in 360-degree oil for roughly 30 seconds per side. Drain on a wire rack. Ice and decorate as desired.
For jelly doughnuts, roll the fried rounds in superfine sugar while the doughnuts are still warm. Attach a pastry tip (ideally a #230 Bismark tip, but just about any good-size tip will do) to the corner of quart-sized zip-lock bag and fill with about a cup of jam. Using a cake tester, gently poke a hole in the side (or bottom) of each doughnut. Fill with about 1 1/2 tablespoons of jam. Eat!
Makes 12-14 doughnuts.
122 thoughts on “Raised Doughnut Recipe”
They look great. But I wish the recipe had the USA equivalent to it. Call me dumb but I just don’t know what 4.2 ounces or 5.8 ounces of flour is. An I don’t have a food scale. A lot of other recipes here have the equivalent to them. But not the good looking doughnuts.
I’ll make that change, Jackie. You’re not the first person to ask me for the volume equivalents. I try to make a habit of putting up both, but sometimes I get rushed and foget.
Yay…that was my request too! Thank you!
Was just wondering if you covered the sponge while it sat overnight. Thanks!
Yes I do, Ashley. Thanks for bringing that up.
Thanks Joe. I really would appreciate it. You recipes look good. And you explain them so well.
Hi, love your website. I was wondering would this recipe work fine making it the night before, refrigerating the dough, then roll and cut and rise,fry that morning?
Hey Alicia! Oh yes, this dough is great for that. In fact that’s mostly how I do it. Why I didn’t think to mention it I have no idea, other than I’m an idiot.
Thanks for the wake-up!
I made the doughnuts as we had talked about, however after rolling the pin over the dough to roll it out it kept retracting and wanting to pull back together. Would adding just a touch of vinegar to the dough help with this or would something else make the dough easier to roll out?
Hi Alicia! When you’ve got a dough that’s very elastic, the best thing to do is to simply let it rest. About ten minutes will suffice, you can rest it on the counter or in the refrigerator, either one is fine. Once the dough has relaxed it will roll easier, though you can relax it again if need be.
Thanks for the recipe! I made them today and the flavor and texture are fantastic. Since the dough is so tender I had a hard time getting the dough with holes into the oil without distorting them. The jelly doughnuts seemed to be easier to handle. Any suggestions on transfering them from towel to oil without deflating or misshaping them?
Hey Amanda! That is indeed a little tricky. In the professional doughnut world they’re proofed on big rectangular racks that are simply lowered into the (rectangular) fryer. I can’t think of a way to replicate that in the home kitchen. I’ve fiddled with splatter guards…but you’d need to buy several, then bend all the handles so the’ll lower into the fry pan. It’s not an easy solution, but I’ll keep thinking!
If I may, when I make your fabulous raised doughnut, I cut as many pieces of parchmin paper (4 inch square) as I need and let each doughnut raised on, then when ready to fry I hold by the paper and transfered to oil with no problem of deflating or misshaping them. the paper will float after 20 or 30 second in the oil, use a tong to remove it. I do the same if I have to fry pâte à choux to make a sweet poutine. I hope my little trick will help.
Thanks, Louise for Québec.
That’s a very cool technique, Louise!
So glad the doughnuts work so well for you. I’m going to try that next time because I’m getting tired or dimple marks from my fingers! In the old days when I made them commercially I just proofed them on trays and lowered the whole thing into the fryer (standard practice in the doughnut industry). Your technique is as close an approximation to that method as I’ve heard about for home donuteers!
Thanks very much!
i suggest use a longer towel, hold the tray nearest you with your left hand. then slowly pull the end of the towel near the pan towards you.
picture it as a manual conveyor belt.
What can I use as a substitute for the Milk Powder? (Preferably non-dairy)
There are several possible non-dairy products that can be used in place of dry milk, just head down to your local health food store. You should be able to find soy milk powder, coconut milk powder or rice milk powder there.
Thanks Joe for everything!
As I see I’m not going to the health food store I put in some mashed potato instead.
Since I was not at the computer when I made this last night -from memory, I shaped it into a rectangle but instead of refrigerating it then, I rolled it right after shaping it into a rectangle and refrigerated it then. Did I kill it? Can I still save it?
I think it will still rise, though mashed potato…hmm…let me know how it goes! 😉
So here are the results! Some rose nicely and some not. The ones that did were delicious, gorgeous and fluffy, light as paper. I don’t think the potato added anything I just put in a drop – maybe 2-3 tablespoons. I do think that the bakeries use an extra strong vanilla or some different flavoring that gives it that unique taste.
Glad at least some of them turned out, Sam! Well done!
hi joe, i love your donuts. i was wondering if i didnt have a mixer, can i do it al by hand ?. i broke my mixer last night. i make a lot of bread by hand so i’m use to effort. what do you think ?
So glad to hear that because, as you know, I’m a doughnut man. That said, I’d never let a trifle like a broken machine get between me and a regular fix. They absolutely can be made by hand. You’ll want the butter a bit softer than normal to ensure that it incorporates well…otherwise you should be good to go! Let me know how they turn out, OK?
Okay, two questions, actually —
First: if I wanted a classic glazed doughnut (and boy, do I!), what would I use for the glaze, and at what point? Just a simple confectioners sugar water concoction?
Second: how do you stay thin around all this amazing stuff? (and you do — your hands don’t lie)
Hey there again!
Yes, a simple icing like this works great: http://www.joepastry.com/2011/on-simple-icing
Just thin it out a little more than normal so it runs all the way down around the sides. Also I got a good chuckle out of your “hands” comment. My wife is a university professor, and as you probably know, in that environment there’s never any shortage of hungry mouths to feed. Grad students especially rely on the kindness of strangers. That’s where everything goes…otherwise I’d eat it all and, well…it would go straight to my hands. 😉
I’ve been on the quest for an icredible yeast doughnut recipe since having an amazing doughnut about a month ago in Brooklyn, NY. I stumbled upon your site yesterday and am excited to give your recipe a try (btw, I’ve never made doughnuts before but am determined!)
Question for you – A lot of other recipes use bread flour instead of AP flour. What characteristics would each flour give to the doughnut, regarding lightness and fluffiness of the inside, crispiness of the outside, tenderness of the overall doughnut?
Great question. Bread flour has more protein (gluten) in it, so that’s going to make the dough more elastic, more capable of holding bubbles of gas and steam. That cam be good for lightness, but the trade-off is a chewier doughnut. It think these doughnuts are plenty light and fluffy without the bread flour, plus they’re nice and tender to the bite. That’s why I prefer all-purpose flour.
Thanks and let me know how they turn out!
I just came across your site looking for a yeast doughnut to make for our annual DoughnutFest (doughnut frying in the backyard with friends!), and can’t wait to try this one out. In years past I’ve used shortening to fry the doughnuts (I think it was on Smitten Kitchen that I read it was often preferable to oil for some reason). What’s your opinion?
There’s lots of information on the site about frying:
However my short answer is that either one will do. A solid shortening will firm back up at room temperature so you won’t have to worry about weeping on bags or boxes. But if you’re just doing a few of them, a liquid oil is more convenient. Let me know how they turn out!
Oh, and one more question– building on Alicia’s question about making the dough completely the night before: After the dough is made, would it go into the fridge immediately and then be pulled out to rise the next day, or does the rise take place before going into the fridge? In either case, how long should it stay at room temp before it’s rolled out for cutting? Thanks!
You’ll want to refrigerate it before the proofing (second rise). It’ll probably take half an hour to warm up then another hour to proof.
Thanks for the question!
Ugh– call me a bad student, but I just want to be sure I do this right (I’m making them this weekend). Should I actually cut the doughnuts before refrigerating them? Thanks for answering all these questions!
I thought I’d taken the refrigeration step out of this (I changed the recipe recently to make it easier). Is there still a reference to refrigerating the finished dough? I think all it calls for now is rising and proofing at room temperature (except for the sponge of course, which does rise overnight).
No reference to refrigerating, just in the comments (on 6/8/11 Alicia asked about making the dough the night before and refrigerating). My last question is a follow-up to questions I asked previously about making the dough in advance. You mentioned refrigerating before the second rise– just wanted to confirm that this was after the dough is cut into rounds.
Ah yes. I understand. Yes, refrigerate them right after cutting. Let them warm and rise in the morning.
Wonderful– thanks again!
I tried this recipe today. Delicious! I didn’t use the sponge but substituted in some sourdough starter that I keep. We gobbled the whole batch up. They are so soft and fluffy.
Thanks for sharing your recipe,
And it’s me pleasure. Thanks for the note!
I can’t find milk powder anywhere. Can I use liquid milk instead of water?
I tried this recipe and followed your instructions, the result was great!! My family and my friends love it, me too…
Thank you for sharing this recipe!
Great to hear it, Midia! Thank you for getting back to me with the results!
For doughnut rings that stayed round I recently tried placing the cut-out dough on individual pieces of aluminum foil to raise, reshaping the dough as needed. I picked up foil and all on a pancake turner and lowered each one into the hot oil that way. It worked like a charm! The doughnut floats free of the foil in a few seconds and the foil can be removed (drippy!) for disposal.
Ingenious! Thanks, Sally!
Question: can ‘White Lily’ brand, all-purpose flour be used in this doughnut recipe? Thanks.
Unfortunately not. There is too little gluten in WhiteLily for the recipe to work. Any other sort of all-purpose will work!
Hi Joe. I am hoping you can help me. I’ve tried making doughnuts 3x so far and it’s failed miserably. I am hoping your recipe will be a success. So far every time I have tried, the dough deflates after the second rise. I don’t know why. Also, this is important, can your recipe be changed to be non-dairy? Thank you!
So the second rising is the problem? When do they deflate? Before or after they go in the fryer?
Ok so they deflate a bit before being fried. Also, they don’t puff while being fried. And the outside gets very brown fast and the inside is still raw. I have been substituting almond milk for the powdered milk and water combination and using coconut oil instead of butter. I tried with extra light olive oil too instead of coconut oil.
Interesting. Those changes shouldn’t be catastrophic to the doughnuts…not to that extent at least. Is the dough extremely slack when you roll it?
Thank you again for your quick response. I really appreciate your help. It’s really nice that you are trying to figure this out with me. I am new to baking, cooking, etc. I only started this past September so maybe that’s why? Thanks again for all your help.
The dough is not slack when I roll it. Maybe I am letting the dough rise too long the second time around? The dough becomes very sticky that second time it rises. The second time the shaped doughnuts spreads really big and that smooth surface disappears exposing a sticky inside. Also, I can’t lift them off the parchment paper. The round dough shapes are soooo sticky.
Someone suggested I use orange juice as a substitute instead of milk because it’s thicker. But I don’t know if that’s really my problem.
(P.S. I tried the cake doughnut method with a cookie scoop/two spoon method and that worked out for the most part. I used almond milk and grapeseed oil in the recipe and fried them in coconut oil).
It’s my pleasure, Lori!
It definitely sounds like they’re over-proofing (second rising too long). They should puff up some, but not to the degree that it sounds. That right there should help a good deal. Let them increase in size maybe 50% and no more than that. Fry them and let me know the results!
Hi Joe, I’ve adapted your recipe to make gluten-free doughnuts, and I must say they’ve been a success. Just had a newbie baker question for you, if I double or triple the recipe, do I have to double or triple the sponge? Thanks very much, your site is extremely helpful and awesome in so many ways.
You flatter me, Carol! Thanks for your generosity!
The answer is yes, you’ll need to double or triple everything. Great news on the adaptation. Very glad it’s working for you!
I noticed when mixing the ingredients for the dough nuts it stated sugar. Is this powered or granulated. Thank you.
Granulated is what I use, but an equal weight of powdered sugar would also work well.
I just made these and they are amazing! I used an ‘OO’ Italian pasta flour and the only difference I did in the process was incorporating the butter into the flour and crumble them before actually kneading…
Half of the batch I baked and the other I fried (wanted to see what textures they obtain). The baked ones has got a more buttery flavour to it whilst the fried ones are very light spongey and with that nice donut crust… yum!
I’ve just been also wondering whether this recipe would benefit using natural yeast / starter? I heard that you can subdue the ‘sour’ flavour from the starter by using baking soda – but I haven’t really tried it yet.
Thanks for the full report! You can indeed use a starter for this recipe in the usual way: by replacing up to a third of the dough with a standard starter. If you try it let me know…I’ll be curious to know what you think!
Cheers and thanks again!
Wow – so thrilled to find your site Joe – so much to learn!! we want our donuts to be light but with a good bite to them – I was thinking of using half all purpose and half bread flour – what are your thoughts?
Thanks very much and welcome! There’s no reason your idea wouldn’t work. The bread flour will definitely add a chew if that’s what you’re after and more volume in the bargain. I’d definitely recommend trying them both ways and see which you prefer.
Cheers and keep me informed!
Not sure if this message was posted so I’ll post again
We are also looking to develop a yeast doughnut recipe from scratch can you assist us?
Happy to do what I can can. Have you made this one? What would you like to do differently?
Thank you for the response, yes we have and we love the recipe.
We would want a larger doughnut with with a softer exterior, our raised doughnuts came out darker than we expected.
Although even with the crispy exterior the doughnuts were still airy and light!
Try lowering your oil temperature 15 to 25 degrees Fahrenheit. That will do two things: keep the doughnuts from darkening more than you like, and prevent too much crisping. These can be made very blonde indeed and once they fully cool, the exterior crust will soften as the fry medium soaks in a little. Which is to say: a lighter cooking and an hour or more of cooling might get you a fair way to your goal.
Let me know how it goes!
Thanks for the response!
Any ideas on size? Can I manipulate the final size by increasing proofing time or by increasing the thickness of the rolled dough?
The size can be whatever you like. Just go ahead and cut them bigger. The dough might need to be a little bit thicker, but not much. Size won’t effect proofing time as the yeast will keep growing no matter what you do. Larger doughnuts will however take longer to heat all the way through, which will require a lower oil temperature. But then we’ve been down that road already!
Joe are you available for onsite consulting?
I absolutely am. I’ve done it for several bakeries and doughnut shops. Do you want to talk by phone?
JOe – thank You so much for being so generous with your knowledge – it has meant so much to me!
You’re very welcome — I love what I do! 😉
Hi Joe me again. We love how light your yeast doughnut dough is – our doughnuts look great but we wánted to try and get more pull apart – I am thinking that is more gluten. – is that right? If so should we mix dough longer before first proof..
When you say “pull apart” do you mean fluffy on her he inside?
As u put it succinclty in ur intro to this post, I’m a would be donut maker who can’t believe his luck for stumbling on ur post with this amazing recipe for yeast raised donuts (I call ‘em yeastnuts). That being said I’ve got just 2questions.
1st: I’ve been wondering, is there rlly a significant difference between using powdered milk and liquid milk? And in ur expert opinion, which do u regard as a better form of milk and why?
2nd: I wana try out a peanut butter and jelly donut recipe using ur recipe here as the base but with homemade unsweetened almond milk. Do u think I shd use a combo of milk powder and the liquid almond milk and @what ratio, to yield the same number of donuts ur recipe yields. Or is it ok to use the almond milk just by itself and @what quantity if the latter option to be ur prefered way to go?
Thank you so much for the kind words! I appreciate them greatly.
Regarding milk powder in the recipe it’s mostly there as a tenderizer, so it’s not essential. You can use liquid milk in the recipe and leave the powdered milk out if you wish. Almond milk would make a fine substitute for the milk as well, not adjustments necessary. Love your peanut butter and jelly doughnut idea, I want to know how it turns out!
hi joe!! i have this restaurant and want to have some donuts for desert
and i want to do them i just have a question you do the sponge mixture one day and the next day yo ad the doughnuts ingridents? i try doing anither recepie but the never ever sponge so im trying yours now. please let me know the answer to my question! and thanks!!!
You can do either one. The sponge left to ferment overnight in the refrigerator will have more flavor. If you prefer not to do that, let the sponge ferment for one hour at room temperature, then proceed.
Let me know what you think!
I had a couple of questions. 1. Is Canola oil the best for frying? What might some other alternative and healthy oils be that do okay at that temperature? (and) 2. What volume of oil are you cooking in? I found that cooking in a large wok of oil didn’t work so good because I could never keep a constant temp. (as soon as I drop a couple of donuts in, the temp drops, I try to correct, then get it too hot, etc. etc…).
Good question. In general you want an oil that’s a.) neutral tasting and b.) has a high tolerance for heat. Canola and vegetable oil both fill that bill, as does shortening. A lot of people like lard as well even though it has a piggy sort of taste. What sort of oils are you thinking about using?
Also you want your oil about 2 inches deep for doughnuts. I’d suggest a cast iron Dutch oven or something like that since as you say, a wok isn’t very user-friendly when it comes to frying. Dutch ovens tend to be both more stable and better at holding heat.
Best of luck with the doughnuts!
I tried this recipe today and they turned out to be DIVINE! One thing though: as I was mixing I had to add extra water to the dough because it was very dry. Is this normal?
Wonderful to hear, Crystal! And yes the “sponge” is very firm on this. The baker who passed the original recipe on to me felt strongly that the drier sponge gave it the finished doughnuts a more distinct flavor. There’s some scientific basis for that belief, since different microbes thrive under different conditions. Some flavor-giving bacteria do better in a drier sponge. Still there’s no reason not to add more water if handling it is an issue. Glad they worked out so well!
Can I use active dry yeast instead of instant yeast
These donuts look incredibly delicious, light, and airy. Obviously I am a fan of the donut, like most people are. Fried dough is always a good time. It would be interesting to try a comparison with a non-yeasted donut and a yeast risen donut and to see how their flavor profiles are different. A natural yeast leaving agent would also be interesting to try because of the natural sour flavor that comes along with a natural leaving agent. The addition of baking soda is said to eliminate the sour flavor, however I have not tested this theory for myself. Either way, I will be sure to give these donuts a try because they look delicious.
I think you’ll like these. The big yeast pockets make them very light and great for filling if you like them Bismarck style! The sponge for these is very firm, so don’t let that bother you, it’s by intent. The Frenchman I got this formula from swore that the drier preferment was favorable to different type of bacteria, and that created a subtle difference in flavor. I don’t know how true that is, but I liked the finished product so much I didn’t dare change it!
Cheers and thanks again for commenting!
I’m in Chicago working my way toward opening my own doughnut shop. I’m being heavily steered toward using mixes but I’d love some professional advice on the “scratch” angle. I don’t have a physical space yet but was also curious if you’d consider consulting when the time is near.
Happy to help any way I can. Send me an email using the link on the upper left and we’ll set up a time to chat by phone.
Hi Joe! So excited that I stumbled upon your blog, I can’t wait to get started on these Friday and fry them Saturday morning!!
I had a couple questions for you,
I was reading a couple other doughnut recipes, and a few say that once the dough it mixed they let it rise at room temp for 2-3 hours, or doubled in size (in a warm place), then they punch it down, after that return it to the fridge and let it rest overnight (preferred) and then make the doughnut shapes, let rest again and then fry off. What are your thoughts on the 3 step resting? Would you recommend just making the dough, rest overnight in fridge, then make doughnuts, rest, fry?
Also, once the butter is added to the dough, how long after should I keep the mixer going? Just until incorporated or longer?
Is non-fat milk powder okay to use?
Where is the best place to proof inside of your home? I live in Northern California where it;s about high 60’s throughout the day.
Sorry for all the questions, and thank you advance for all of your help!
Nice to hear from you! On the resting, like bread there are a lot of ways you can go. I created this recipe for large production where time is of the essence, but you don’t want to sacrifice flavor. I think it tastes pretty good, but if you want to go the extra mile you can rest them in the fridge once they’re cut for another night. They’ll probably rise in the fridge to one degree or another, and will probably only need half an hour to warm up and maybe another 15 minutes to rise they last 15% of the way or so. You’ll have to experiment but that’s a fine way to go as well!
As for mixing the butter, once it’s completely in, you’re good. And non-fat milk powder will work fine. Proofing may be a little difficult if it’s that cool. Maybe try the oven (turned off). If that’s still too cool, turn the oven on to the lowest possible temperature for about 20 minutes, turn it off and let it sit for 5 minutes, then put the doughnuts in. That should do the trick.
And no problem on the questions — that’s what I’m here for!
Thank you so much for the quick response! Can’t wait to start these on Friday!
Keep me informed!
and just to clarify,
proof then cut the doughnuts into shapes and then rest overnight? or rest the dough in the fridge after its been proofed then roll/cut the next morning before frying?
(hopefully not too confusing!)
If you want an overnight rest to further develop the flavor of the finished dough (not the sponge), the best time to do it is after shaping. So, after the dough has risen the first time, roll the dough and cut the doughnuts, lay them out on a sheet pan and cover the pan with plastic wrap, then hustle the pan into the fridge. The freezer might be even better for the first half hour, to really put the hammer down on the yeast. Once the doughnuts are fully chilled and have stopped rising, put them into the fridge for the night. When you’re ready to fry, take the pan out of the fridge and let the doughnuts sit for half an hour to take off the chill, then maybe another 10-30 minutes until they’re completed their rise. Then fry.
That’s my best advice assuming I understand your goal correctly. Let me know how they turn out!
doesnt measuring by weight work better then by volume?
Yes in general it’s better. Is there something here that’s not in weight? Other than eggs and things like salt and flavorings I mean. Those get really annoying when done by weight since you have to get into very tiny measures that scales often lie about.
I have to say though that the insistence on weight measurement can be overblown, especially for things like bread, cookies and quick breads where a little inexactitude never hurt anyone. 😉
Cheers and thanks for the question,
What can I use as a substitute for yeast?
Ummm….that’s a hard one. My I suggest a cake doughnut instead? They’re even better! 😉
These were fantastic! I found your recipe when I went searching for a recipe that did not use shortening.
I used the parchment paper tip—and finally made doughnuts that were nice and round. I did need to substitute King Arthur Cake Flour for the all purpose flour. I normally only have on hand this particular brand of cake flour or bread flour. I can’t imagine the doughnuts being any lighter or fluffier than were made.
My family is devouring them as I write–not sure we’re going to be able to have any left to see how they are as day old doughnuts.
Sorry for the late reply. I’m glad these worked so well for you! As a doughnut freak, I’ve spent a lot of time on these recipes, so it always delights me to hear postive reports. Hope you’re making some for the holidays! 😉
Hi Jo, I know you’re not around here much but I’ll post anyway, just incase you read this or one of your readers has the answer.
I’ve made this recipe many time, hundreds of doughnuts, if not more. I was beginning to think of myself as a doughnut master. But yesterday I made my usual batch for a local store and they came out awfully! I had to cancel my stall and will experiment this weekend. I made them in 4 batches, so it’s something I did to all 4.
They came out with flat to concave bottoms (the side in the fryer first), greasy and pretty flat really.
I used two different batches of yeast, so it’s not that. The only thing I wonder is if I overproofed in my hurry to get them done using a warm oven. Any insights would be appreciated!
Oh, one more thing. We seem to have to change our shortening pretty regularly, even though there seems to be a thought process that you should just have to top up. I’m wondering if it’s the flour from rolling causing the oil to brown and flavour?
I’d look at proofing times first since that’s usually the culprit when you get a collapse like that. The structure gets over-extended and weak, then when it hits the heat the bubbles pop and…you get the idea. If shorter times don’t proof send me an email and we’ll work the problem.
Greetings from Malaysia! I tried making your doughnuts today and they were amazing!!! I have tried making doughnuts over the past year and they were never as soft and fluffy as yours or they didn’t taste as good as yours. I just want to thank you for sharing. They were devoured completely by my family the moment I arranged them on a plate. Thank you again!
WONDERFUL to hear that, Lisa! Few things make a family as happy as fresh doughnuts. So glad they worked so well for you.
Please sent me your email i would like to make commercial doughnuts
I stumbled across your recipe last nite and immediately had a gut feeling about it so i switched recipes and made yours and WOW! I got exactly what i was looking for in a donut,Light,Soft and Airy…tastes absolutely amazing and i sincerely loved them.
I am going into commercial donuts and i would like to discuss via email. Is that ok?
Thank you again Joe!
Yay! And great news, Judith!
By all means get in touch via email. I’d be happy to discuss doughnuts with you. firstname.lastname@example.org
Greetings from Pakistan. I stumbled on your website while searching for a doughnut recipe. It’s a pleasure going through the details for each recipe and how clearly each one is explained.
Tried the doughnuts today and all were devoured despite the fact that I had doubled the quantity!
They turned out amazing!
Though I had to add a little more flour because the dough was too soft and too sticky and it was quite a challenge to handle it but the end results were so very tasty! Thanks for sharing!
Hello Pakistan! Absolutely delighted you found me, Sajida! And I’m even more gratified that the recipe worked so well. It’s true that ingredients (like flour) perform differently in different parts of the world, so it’s not surprising that you needed to improvise a bit. The main thing is that they tasted good.
So congratulations on your victory, and please do come back. Should you have any questions about any of the recipes, I will be happy to answer them.
Thanks so much for sharing this. Will soon try this. Please i want to ask how long can this stay before it get spoilt. Then how can i preserve my donut to last for some days or week/more? Or is dea any preservative for donut?. Thanks!
Hello! These doughnuts will go stale fairly quickly. Most raised doughnuts are completely stale after about two days. They can be frozen, however. In a freezer they will keep for weeks. If freezing is not possible you can try adding a little citric acid (vitamin C) to the batter. It is a natural preservative which may help keep them soft for longer.
Good luck Fatimoh!
I am so glad I found your website. Thank you so much for sharing your knowledge freely with everyone. I will be trying your recipe over the weekend.
To clarify, just the sponge needs to rest overnight in the fridge. And the rest can be done in the morning? How long is too long for it to rest in the fridge? Like is 10hrs plus too much?
When the donut is filled how long can it last for business purpose or what would you suggest.
For a home based donut business, will it be easy to double your recipe? Or do I need to contact you for such? Like if you have one that is double or tripled already.
Thank you for the very kind words! I’ll be curious to know how the recipe goes for you. And yes you are correct, the sponge is all that needs to be refrigerated. You can keep the sponge for up to 3 days in the refrigerator without any problems.
Filled or unfilled, a raised doughnut is fresh for only about 18 hours after it’s made, but that can be a good long time, even if you make the doughnuts the night before you sell them.
Also the recipe can be scaled up to whatever size you need, just based on the recipe that’s here.
Have fun and let me know how it goes!
Hi joe can i use soft wheat flour for this
Yes, Sunny, though it won’t give you as high a rise. It will still work, however.
Thank you very much. I am from Nigeria and have gradually become an accomplished home cook and baker – from thick Greek yoghurt to pastries, etc. I am type 2 diabetic so I always add puréed veg to my bakings, eggs and plenty powdered milk to help reduce the sugar. I added I cup puréed white radish, 4 Large eggs and 1/4 cup milk. The donuts were out of this world. Thanks. By the way, its good you are back
Nnenna, you have humbled me both with your praise and your inventiveness. Thank you for a wonderful comment. I’m so glad you got in touch. Enjoy the doughnuts, and please come back and visit soon!
I’ve always refrigerated overnight for the first proof (pre cut) and then cut, rested and fried the next morning. I see in the comments you recommend proofing, cutting and then refrigerating for the second proof.
Is it possible to refrigerate for the first proof with this recipe? Hoping to add doughnuts to my bakery’s menu and not sure we have the fridge space to hold all the cut donuts overnight!
Hey there, Joe, thanks for all this.
I’m curious, why do you put the egg in the sponge? As a former pro bread baker, I’ve never heard of this. Is it just because the sponge is on the drier side, you need the hydration that the egg provides? (Though it’s what? 88% water without the egg, which isn’t really that dry—preferments can sometimes be just like bread dough, at 65% or so.) Or is there some other reason?
Great comment. And for sure you don’t see this in the bread world very much. However you do see it a lot in the realm of pastry and viennoiserie. It’s a common preferment technique for things like brioche, croissant and Danish. As you already hit on, it’s mostly about hydration. However adding egg instead of water is also a way to add structure-giving protein and (of course) some fat to the dough in the bargain. As countless Viennese bakers have no doubt said to themselves over the years: why add water when you can use fat instead?
So that’s the reason as far as I am aware. Many thanks for a great analysis.