Great Rice Pudding Lovers of History: Ulysses S. Grant

His name was actually Hiram Ulysses Grant, but that’s what happens when you’re born in 1822 and someone spells your name wrong on a military school application. You suddenly get an “S” stuck in there. Forever. Grant put up with it, but made it clear that it never stood for anything other than “S”. He had a lot more on his mind than middle names anyway.

Grant was and is to this day America’s greatest general (Eisenhower being a very close contender for the title). He is also an icon to the late bloomers of the world, those of us still hoping that some day our talents will align with history in such a way that we’ll be propelled to greatness. Indeed when the Civil War broke out Grant was considered by many — especially his immediate family and in-laws — to be a has-been. A sometimes drunk and hopeless businessman, he’d been reduced to working in his father’s tannery shop, tying up packages because he was too socially awkward for sales. He was 39 years old.

Grant had already been a soldier of course. He’d gone to West Point and had fought in the Mexican-American War. There he had distinguished himself in battle, a somber but unusually determined and courageous officer. An intelligent and sensitive sort also, he remarked on several occasions that he both liked the Mexicans and regretted U.S. provocations of them. Yet if there was one thing that defined Grant above all else was his dedication to duty. He pressed on unflinchingly.

It was this trait that Lincoln valued so much twenty years later when the Civil War broke out. Not a year out from his dad’s leather goods store, Grant was promoted to general after his performance at Fort Donelson. There Grant and his Union army squared off against 12,000 fortified Confederates under the command of Grant’s former infantry buddy, Simon Buckner. Grant quickly surrounded the fort, ending the fight after just a few days. Buckner surrendered with the expectation of generous terms because, well, Grant owed him money. Their correspondence went like this:


In consideration of all the circumstances governing the present situation of affairs at this station I propose to the commanding officers of the Federal forces the appointment of commissioners to agree upon terms of capitulation of the forces and post under my command, and in that view suggest an armistice until 12 o’clock to-day.


Yours of this date, proposing armistice and appointment of commissioners to settle terms of capitulation, is just received. No terms except unconditional and immediate surrender can be accepted. I propose to move immediately upon your works.

After than and forever after “U.S.” Grant would be known as “Unconditional Surrender” Grant, and he was promoted to Major General. Grant would show this sort of iron determination all throughout the war. Where other Civil War generals on both sides jockeyed, played for time and generally tried to outwit or outlast the other, Grant pressed forward. Thoughtfully, but with resolve. Indeed Grant saw more clearly than others just how bloody the Civil War was about to become. He perceived that unlike earlier conflicts waged by kings with hired armies, the American Civil War would be fought in the total war style that Napoleon had invented half a century earlier: with entire societies pitted against one another in an ideological grudge match. As Churchill would later say in anticipation of World War I “the wars of peoples will be more terrible than the wars of kings.” Battles would be personal and vengeful and body counts would be high. It’s certainly because Grant expected horrific casualties at sites like Shiloh that he kept going in spite of them, though not without the sadness that is evident in virtually every picture ever taken of him.

Grant’s grit served him well right up to his epic face off with Robert E. Lee and the Army of Northern Virginia. Lee was a man of great charisma but also of staggering imagination and ingenuity. Also a natural engineer, Lee excelled at creating earthworks and entrenchments that confounded his opponents. On paper he was a superior general, yet he was unprepared for Grant’s stripped down, no-nonsense style of fighting. Once Grant had engaged the Army of Northern Virginia, he wouldn’t disengage. Like a pit bull latched to Lee’s ankle, he took huge punishment, yet he succeeded in dragging Lee further and further from his home territory and his base of supply. Lee’s army eventually starved. And that, as they say, was that. All the genius in the world is useless if your troops have no ammo or anything to eat.

Later in a small farmhouse in Appomattox, during the signing of the articles of surrender, the Confederate top brass could only shake their heads at the simplistic strategy that defeated their hero general. Many did so at Grant himself, who they remembered from the Mexican campaign twenty years earlier. Not so much for his fighting ability has for his terrible portrayal of Desdemona, the female lead in Othello, a play that Grant’s company put on during one of their many long waits. James Longstreet, a Confederate General who was present at Appomattox, had been part of the cast and had personally complained about Grant’s awful acting. At the time he’d insisted that the company go to the extreme of bringing an actual woman over from New Orleans to play the part, all to no avail. One can only imagine what Longstreet was thinking watching the surrender ceremony. The last time I saw this guy he was in drag. Now I’m surrendering to him. Lord, life is crazy.

I tell you all this because now, knowing what you know about Ulysses Grant, you’ll understand why his favorite dessert was a dish as plain as rice pudding. It was one of the only two foods he ever got excited about, the other being roasted turkey. Not sexy either. But that was Grant: what you saw was pretty much what you got.

16 thoughts on “Great Rice Pudding Lovers of History: Ulysses S. Grant”

  1. Pastry expert and Civil War buff? You’re a treasure. If you haven’t already read it, I heartily recommend Grant and Sherman: The Friendship That Won the Civil War by Charles Bracelen Flood.

    1. I always love another book idea. Thanks Rachel! Have you read the one on Grant and Twain? It’s a charmer.

      – Joe

  2. Thanks for all the history about rice pudding. I never would have thought there was that much to know about a lovely but plain dish. It’s this kind of interesting stories that keep me reading every post. Your recipes work for me every time as well. Keep up the good work.
    If you get some of those recipes for rice pudding types from other cultures (like the Turkish and Thai ones noted) could you set up another section of your site labeled something like: “Untested Home Recipes From Readers” with a space for others to comment on how well the recipe worked out. [My family recipes are famous for leaving out steps or ingredients – as “everyone knows how to do that!”] I would like to try some of those “untested” recipes, as well.

    1. Thanks so much, Lloyd! And I shall do that. There are some very interesting rice puddings out there and other readers have promised me recipes!

      – Joe

  3. I guess I come by liking the rice pudding naturally (last name is Grant). Interesting. He’s always gotten such a bad rap in history as being a drunkard. Nice to know that was a minor aspect and the rest of his history is more stellar. Now when I eat rice pudding I will do it with family pride! (not that I have any family connection that I know of!)

    1. Fabulous, Linda! Nice to know I have a Grant along for the ride. It’s funny, if people know one thing about Grant it’s that he drank too much. That was only occasionally true, but it tended to occur when he was separated from his wife. When he was “on-task” as they say, he was sober. Today I think people might call him a “binge drinker.” Happily for him he had a faithful aid by the name of Rawlins I think it was, who kept him away from bottles and protected him from the press when he lapsed.

      Cheers and thanks!

      – Joe

  4. “I propose to fight it out along this line if it takes all summer”
    – Grant

    All previous Union Generals had always pulled back after an engagement win or lose. Grant would not. Given the porous nature of communications in DC Lee must have heard these words and knew what it meant for him and his band of treasonous human traffickers.

    The war was over on July 4, 1963. It ended not with Pickets Charge but with Grant, firmly clamped on Vicksburg refusing to relent, the city fell and the South was cut in two. Had Grant been in McClellan’s place Lee’s army would never have made it back to Virginia and the war would literally been over in July 1863.

    Despite his leadership in war and time as President of the US, he died very nearly broke but any man who knocked on his door and said he had fought under him was given something, food, clothes, money – not one was ever denied.

    1. Funny that shortly after his death his family became rich as a result of his memoirs! Thank Mark Twain for that! Poor U.S. never could make a buck at anything. Ah well…he had other skills. Great addition, Frankly!

      – Joe

    2. Well said! It’s true, Grant was a generous man and a good soldier…it’s a pity that jealousy kept him out of command as long as it did…tens of thousands of lives might have been saved.

      On a related note, not to U.S. Grant himself but to the ACW: how many people are going to Gettysburg for the 150th this year? They’re opening a new museum on Seminary Ridge…squeee!!!! Can’t wait! (Joshua Lawrence Chamberlain is another favorite.)

      1. I didn’t know that, Michelle. As the son of a Civil War fanatic I should have! Thanks very much for the alert!

        – Joe

  5. As for rice pudding – I grew up on the cardamom stuff of Scandinavia. Very good with or without raisins. But for the last 10-15 years I have been tinkering with making a specific Indian version they make at a restaurant near by. I don’t have it exactly yet but I’ll share the recipe so far if you want.

    Sorry about the Grant rant but the ACW is a pet topic to me, I have read over 200 books on the subject and tend to get wound up 😉

    1. And why not, Frankly? It’s a great subject. I grew up with a Civil War buff — my father! It’s in the blood. Do send along a recipe once you’re happy with it!

      – Joe

  6. First-time reader…I have to admit I came here to see if there was a favorite recipe of Grant’s (presumably his wife’s, as much as he adored her and was a family man at heart), and was disappointed to find no recipe at all. That said, the disappointment was minor, and this post had me chuckling, as Grant is one of my favorite Civil War personalities–his buddy Sherman is another.

    1. Sorry I don’t have anything genuine, Michelle! But welcome and thanks for the kind comments. Come back when you can,

      – Joe

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *