thumb image

Where do burekas come from?

Probably Turkey. However there is some interesting literature out there on the subject. Some of it argues that burekas have a sort of pre-history as small portable pies eaten by nomads wandering the Asian steppes some 1500 years ago. That theory may or may not be accurate. Burekas are hand pies, and some form of hand pie can be traced to most every wheat eating culture on or near the Eurasian Continent.

Did Culture X invent the hand pie? Or did they just come up with their own word for it? Perhaps they invented the pie and the word. Or were conquered by a people who did. Or perhaps Culture X and Culture Z invented their pies and words independently. One can go mad trying to pin down definitive answers to these sorts of questions. Of all forms of history, food history is by far the most nebulous and speculative. Mostly because the archaeological evidence was long ago digested.

Me, I’m just an armchair food historian, so I’m free to follow my own lines of inquiry in regard these sorts of questions. What interests me about bourekas is the way in which similar words are used to describe similar preparations (i.e. flaky little pies) all around the Mediterranean and Adriatic. You’ve got the burek in the Balkans, the burriche in Italy, the bourek in Greece, the boreg in Armenia, the bureka in Israel, the brik in Tunisia, the boureka in Algeria, the briouat in Morocco, and the bourekita in Spain.

Now me, I take a look at that and think: what do most of those places have in common? If you said the Ottomans, an extra börek for you. The Ottomans had conquered pretty much that entire area (with the notable exceptions of Italy and Spain) by about 1500 A.D.. It seems reasonable to assume that when the Ottomans came, they brought their hand pies with them.

Of course the question can be posed: who introduced the börek to the Ottomans? Possibly no one. The Ottomans’ love of flaky things is well documented. They may well have invented burekas themselves. Or perhaps burekas entered the Empire by way of those West Asian nomads. Or, just perhaps, burekas were introduced to the Ottoman Empire from the other direction, from Spain, by way the Sephardic Jews, who were expelled from Spain in the wake of Ferdinand and Isabella’s infamous Alhambra Decree. They were known to make pies, there were a lot of them (up to 100,000 by some estimates), and they dispersed themselves widely around the Ottoman Empire where they exerted a considerable cultural influence.

Could the Sephardim have brought small, flaky hand pies to the Ottomans? It has been so argued. How much evidence there is for that claim I couldn’t tell you. Based on the flaky dough, I still tend to think that burekas originated in the Middle East or Turkey somewhere. But then I could be wrong, could I not?

2 thoughts on “Where do burekas come from?”

  1. Interesting, as always. One thing about burekas in Israel. (I have never eaten them elsewhere, now that I think of it. I don’t know why, they’re certainly to be found everywhere.) But in Israel they are more of a snack, or part of a meal, rather than a meal in and of itself. When I think of hand pies, I think of a meal. I may be wrong, but hand pies make me think of big substantial things. Burekas in Israel are usually small. Of course I can eat ten of them in a sitting, which would be a meal and then some. But they’re little, served along with other things as part of a breakfast buffet, for example, or part of the light evening meal. I don’t know if this would make them distinct from other hand pies.

    1. Hey Chana!

      Very astute comment. I’ve never been to Israel (next year!) but I’ve heard tell that bourekas are generally quite small. Though size doesn’t necessarily disqualify something from being a hand pie. Empanadas and pierogis are generally small, and Asian potsticker dumplings (which technically meet the definition of hand pies) are even smaller. So I think it’s one of those “size doesn’t matter” cases. In the southwest of England — where I have been, and indeed lived — the hand pies (pasties) are truly massive. If those are the frame of reference, I completely get where you’re coming from!

      Thanks for a great comment!

      – Joe

Leave a Reply to joepastry Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *